Using the Criteria listed on the left, see if you can quickly identify which website on Shostakovich would be "best" for my academic research!
1. Who is the author?
What credentials does the author have? If an individual author is not named who is the editor or sponsor? If the source is a web site, is there a link to a "home page" to see who is sponsoring the page?
2. What date was the information published and/or updated?
Is your topic time-sensitive so that you can only use the most updated information or is your topic more historically oriented?
3. Are there any special features such as a "works cited" to back up the information?
If there's not an actual "works cited," are there any internal references to other sources? If yes, what kind of sources are they? Do these sources supplement the information given? If links are provided, do the links work?
4. What is the overall purpose and tone?
Who is the intended audience? If the source is a web site, you can check the domain name for clues (.edu, .org, .com, .mil, .net) to determine what type of page this might be. Is there an "about" or "what is" link from either the information page or the "home page" that outlines the purpose of the pages? Are they trying to sell something?
5. What type of actual content are you getting?
Does it seem to offer opinions only? Is the author only offering their biased view of the topic or do they present multiple sides of the issue? To what depth does the source cover the topic? Does it seem to be a "surface" treatment? Are you getting a background overview, thorough coverage or an in-depth analysis for specific aspects of your topic?
6. Based on your answers to questions 1-5, do you still feel confident in using the source for your research needs? Why or why not?